Why is it exactly that anything 'sexy' is automatically the worst crime according to many Muslims? I don't remember the Qur'an or Hadith teaching that, and I don't fully understand this attitude myself.
It's a mix of many things I suppose, first the embarrassment and shame that sex is viewed with in many places and families. Sex isn't a bad thing, it should be taught in a healthy manner. Sex within marriage is a good thing, just like
kids within marriage is a good thing or
love within marriage is a good thing.
Secondly, it's probably insecurity. The insecurity of men that have been brought up to think that they can't control their own penises, and that if they harrass a woman it's her fault (And what about those sheikhs that say most of the blame of rape goes to the woman for being dressed provocatively?).
But I don't understand why ladies judge other ladies on whether she wears hijab or not, or how she dresses. Personally, to me, a muslimah is a muslimah. Why has it become like the 6th pillar of Islam for us girls? Why is it the defining factor? If people must judge us then why not measure our Islam by our prayer, faith, charity, kindess or Islamic manners? But sometimes our minds are made up just by looking at her clothes, and nobody bothers whether that woman follows the 5 pillars or not. There's way more to Muslim women than clothes. I hope we don't continue to demean ourselves and our sisters by acting like there isn't.
There is no compulsion in religion.
al Baqara - 256
Below are 2 pictures of famous Muslim faces in the Middle East. One of them is a wife, a popular singer and dancer. The other orchestrated the death of about 3,000 civilians. Including Muslims. (not that their religion matters.)
So which is more respected? Before I came to Egypt, and got to know Egypt, I thought the media was exaggerating. I thought that what they say about them wasn't true.
But some of it was.
Many people think that Osama bin Laden is a generally good man who made a big mistake. Nearly everyone condemns what happened on September 11, 2001 - but they won't say he's evil. They won't say that this 1 action defines him. They'll talk about all the good things he's done, they'll defend him.
On the other hand, Haifa never killed anyone. But she does look hot and she does dance provocatively. She's the devil itself, according to some. This one action
does define her. Her appearance in public isn't Islamic, but why is it worse than what Osama bin Laden did?
You don't know what is in people's hearts. You can see Haifa's downfalls straightaway, but the sins other people may be hiding could be 1,000 times worse. She might be a great wife to her husband, she might pray 5 times per day. Do you know how many outwardly pious muslims, hijabis & guys with beards, don't even bother to pray 5 times per day?
None of us are perfect; if someone acts and dresses perfectly in public they will definitely have a downfall in private.
So to wrap it up:
Why is being sexy a bigger taboo than mass murder? My answer; insecurity both within society and inside ourselves.